Benefits Benchmarking: How Does Your Business Compare?

As a Long Island business owner, you know that offering competitive employee benefits is crucial for attracting and retaining good people. But how do you know if your benefits package truly stacks up against what other companies are offering? That's where benefits benchmarking comes in – and it's simpler than you might think.

What Is Benefits Benchmarking?

Benefits benchmarking is like comparison shopping, but for employee benefits packages. Instead of comparing prices on office supplies or equipment, you're comparing what other similar businesses offer their employees in terms of health insurance, retirement plans, paid time off, and other perks.

Think of it as market research for your benefits program. Just as you might research competitor pricing before setting your service rates, benchmarking helps you understand what's considered "standard" or "competitive" in your industry and region.

How Benefits Benchmarking Works

The process involves several key steps that help you get a clear picture of where you stand:

Step 1: Define Your Comparison Group
You'll want to compare against businesses that are similar to yours – same industry, similar size, and preferably in the Long Island area. A 25-person accounting firm in Nassau County shouldn't necessarily benchmark against a 500-person manufacturing company in Ohio.

Step 2: Identify Key Metrics
Common benchmarking points include employer contribution percentages for health insurance, types of medical plans offered, dental and vision coverage, retirement plan matching, paid time off policies, and additional perks like flexible work arrangements.

Step 3: Gather Data
Information comes from industry surveys, benefits consultants, professional associations, and sometimes informal networking with other business owners. The key is getting reliable, recent data that reflects current market conditions.

Step 4: Analyze and Plan
Once you have the data, you can see where your benefits are competitive, where they might be lacking, and where you might be overspending without getting much value.

Why Smart Employers Use Benchmarking

Benefits benchmarking isn't just an academic exercise – it directly impacts your bottom line and your ability to build a strong team.

Attract Better Candidates: When job seekers compare offers, they're not just looking at salary. A comprehensive benefits package can be the deciding factor, especially for experienced professionals who understand the value of good health insurance and retirement benefits.

Retain Your Best People: Employees who feel their benefits are below market standards become flight risks. Regular benchmarking helps you spot potential retention issues before they become resignation letters.

Control Costs Strategically: Benchmarking reveals where you might be overpaying for benefits that employees don't highly value, allowing you to redirect those dollars toward more impactful offerings.

Make Informed Decisions: Instead of guessing what benefits to offer, you're making data-driven decisions based on what actually works in your market.

What Employees Really Care About

From the employee perspective, competitive benefits provide peace of mind and financial security. They want to know their family's healthcare is covered without breaking their personal budget, that they're building toward retirement, and that their employer values work-life balance.

Employees often don't understand the full value of their benefits package unless it's communicated clearly. When they do understand – and when they see that your offerings are competitive – it builds loyalty and job satisfaction.

For many Long Island families, where the cost of living is high, comprehensive benefits can make the difference between financial stress and financial stability.

Key Considerations for Your Business

When embarking on benefits benchmarking, keep these factors in mind:

• Local Market Matters: Long Island's job market and cost of living are unique. National averages might not reflect what you're actually competing against locally.
• Industry Specifics: Medical practices compete for talent differently than law firms, and nonprofits face different budget constraints than for-profit professional services.
• Total Compensation Picture: Benefits are just one piece of the puzzle. Sometimes a slightly lower salary with excellent benefits wins out over higher pay with minimal coverage.
• Employee Demographics: A younger workforce might prioritize different benefits than employees nearing retirement.

How Benton Oakfield Simplifies Benchmarking

At Benton Oakfield, we understand that most business owners don't have time to research industry surveys and crunch benefits data. Our analytics and benchmarking services take this complexity off your plate.

We maintain current benchmarking data specific to Long Island businesses and can show you exactly how your benefits package compares to similar companies in Nassau and Suffolk Counties. More importantly, we help you interpret that data and make strategic decisions about where to invest your benefits dollars for maximum impact.

We also ensure your employees understand the full value of their benefits package – because competitive benefits only help with retention if employees actually know what they have.

Ready to see how your benefits stack up against the competition? Contact us today for a comprehensive benchmarking analysis tailored to your Long Island business.

Compliance Note: Benefit plan rules and tax implications vary based on company size and location. This guide is for educational purposes only. Please contact your Benton Oakfield representative to discuss how this applies to your specific situation.

Photo by Jopwell on Pexels