Captive Insurance for Employee Benefits: A Guide for SMBs

If you're a small to medium business owner on Long Island, you've probably watched your employee benefit costs climb year after year. Traditional insurance premiums seem to increase regardless of your company's actual claims experience. What if there was a way to gain more control over these costs while potentially reducing them? Enter captive insurance – a strategy that's becoming increasingly accessible to smaller employers.

What Is Captive Insurance?

Think of captive insurance as creating your own insurance company. Instead of paying premiums to a traditional insurance carrier that pools your risk with thousands of other companies, you form or join a captive that focuses specifically on your industry or risk profile.

A captive insurance company is a subsidiary that provides insurance coverage to its parent company and related entities. For employee benefits, this means your captive can insure your health, dental, disability, or other benefit plans. You're essentially cutting out the middleman and keeping more control over your insurance dollars.

For smaller employers, group captives are the most practical option. These allow multiple companies to band together and share the ownership and benefits of a captive insurance structure.

How Captive Insurance Works for Employee Benefits

Here's how the process typically unfolds:

• Formation or Joining: Your company either joins an existing group captive or works with others to form a new one. Group captives are particularly attractive for companies with 25-200 employees.
• Premium Structure: Instead of paying traditional insurance premiums, you pay into the captive. This includes money for claims, administrative costs, reserves, and reinsurance.
• Claims Management: The captive pays your employees' benefit claims, just like traditional insurance. However, you have more visibility into where your money goes.
• Profit Sharing: If the captive performs well financially – meaning claims are lower than expected – members may receive profit distributions or premium credits.
• Risk Control: You maintain more control over plan design, provider networks, and wellness programs that can impact costs.

The key difference is that you're now an owner, not just a customer. Good performance benefits you directly through lower costs or profit sharing.

Why Employers Choose Captive Insurance

The primary motivation is cost control. Traditional insurance carriers need to generate profits for shareholders and maintain large reserve funds. With a captive, you eliminate much of that overhead and keep more of the unused premiums.

Cash flow improvement is another major benefit. Captives often provide more predictable costs and better cash flow management compared to traditional insurance renewals that can spike unexpectedly.

Many employers also appreciate the increased transparency. You can see exactly where your benefit dollars go, rather than having costs buried in complex insurance company financials.

From a competitive standpoint, captive insurance can help you offer robust benefits while controlling costs, making it easier to attract and retain quality employees in Long Island's competitive job market.

What Employees Experience

From your employees' perspective, very little changes in their day-to-day benefit usage. They still receive the same ID cards, use the same provider networks, and file claims the same way.

However, employees may benefit from enhanced programs that captives can afford to implement, such as improved wellness initiatives, better customer service, or additional benefit options that might be cost-prohibitive under traditional insurance.

The stability that comes with captive insurance can also benefit employees through more consistent coverage and fewer disruptive plan changes driven by insurance carrier decisions.

Key Considerations for Captive Insurance

Captive insurance isn't right for every employer. The ideal candidate typically has a stable workforce, good claims experience, and strong financial management. Companies with high employee turnover or poor claims history may not see the same benefits.

Financial commitment is important to understand. While captives can reduce long-term costs, they may require higher upfront capital and more complex financial management than traditional insurance.

You'll also need to consider regulatory requirements. Captives are subject to insurance regulations and require proper governance and oversight.

Industry fit matters too. Captives work particularly well for professional service firms, medical practices, and other businesses with relatively predictable risk profiles.

How Benton Oakfield Helps Navigate Captive Insurance

Evaluating whether captive insurance makes sense for your Long Island business requires careful analysis of your current costs, claims history, and financial situation. At Benton Oakfield, we help small and medium businesses explore alternative funding strategies including captive insurance arrangements.

We work with established group captives and can help you understand the financial implications, regulatory requirements, and ongoing management responsibilities. Our goal is to ensure you have all the information needed to make an informed decision about whether captive insurance aligns with your business objectives.

Because captive insurance involves complex financial and regulatory considerations, having an experienced benefits advisor is crucial for success.

Ready to explore whether captive insurance could benefit your business? Contact our team to discuss your specific situation and learn about captive options available to Long Island employers.

Compliance Note: Benefit plan rules and tax implications vary based on company size and location. This guide is for educational purposes only. Please contact your Benton Oakfield representative to discuss how this applies to your specific situation.

Photo by Christina Morillo on Pexels