Continuation Coverage Beyond COBRA for NY Businesses

When employees leave your company, they don't just lose their paycheck—they lose their health insurance too. Most business owners know about COBRA, the federal law that lets former employees continue their health coverage temporarily. But what many don't realize is that New York has its own continuation coverage laws that can extend these protections even further.

If you're a Long Island business owner offering group health insurance, understanding these state continuation requirements isn't just good practice—it's legally required compliance that could save your company from costly penalties.

What Is State Continuation Coverage?

Think of state continuation coverage as COBRA's extended cousin. While federal COBRA requires employers with 20 or more employees to offer continuation coverage, New York state law casts a wider net. New York's continuation provisions, often called "mini-COBRA" laws, apply to smaller employers and can provide longer coverage periods than federal requirements.

Here's the key difference: if your business has fewer than 20 employees, federal COBRA doesn't apply to you. But New York state law still requires you to offer continuation coverage to eligible employees and their dependents who lose coverage due to certain qualifying events.

How New York Continuation Coverage Works

The process works similarly to federal COBRA, but with some important distinctions. When an employee experiences a qualifying event—like termination, reduction in hours, or divorce—they must be notified of their right to continue coverage under state law.

Qualifying events under New York law typically include job termination (except for gross misconduct), reduction in work hours, death of the covered employee, divorce or legal separation, and loss of dependent child status. The employee then has a specific period to elect continuation coverage and begin paying premiums.

Unlike federal COBRA's typical 18-month continuation period, New York may offer different duration periods depending on the qualifying event and the specific insurance policy terms. Some situations may allow for coverage continuation of up to 36 months.

The employee pays the full premium cost—both their portion and what you previously contributed as the employer—plus a small administrative fee. This means no ongoing cost to your business once the employee leaves, but you're still responsible for facilitating the process.

Why Long Island Employers Should Care

Offering proper continuation coverage isn't just about legal compliance—it's a competitive advantage in today's tight labor market. When potential employees are comparing job offers, knowing they won't face an immediate coverage gap if something happens gives them peace of mind.

For professional service firms, medical practices, and other knowledge-based businesses common on Long Island, this benefit can be the deciding factor for quality candidates choosing between opportunities. It demonstrates that your company thinks beyond just the immediate employment relationship.

From a risk management perspective, proper compliance protects your business from potential lawsuits and penalties. State insurance regulators take continuation coverage violations seriously, and the costs of non-compliance far exceed the administrative burden of doing it right.

What Your Employees Actually Get

For your employees, state continuation coverage provides crucial bridge protection during life transitions. Consider a dental office employee who gets divorced—under New York law, their ex-spouse may be eligible for extended coverage, preventing a gap that could lead to expensive medical bills or deferred care.

This coverage maintains the same benefits, provider networks, and prescription coverage they had while employed. The only change is who pays the premium. For many employees, this continuity is worth the temporary premium increase while they transition to new employment or find alternative coverage.

Employees particularly value this benefit because it eliminates the risk of coverage gaps that could make them uninsurable later due to pre-existing conditions, even though federal law provides some protections in this area.

Key Considerations for Implementation

Implementing state continuation coverage requires attention to several details. First, your group health insurance policy must include the appropriate continuation provisions that comply with New York state requirements. Not all policies automatically include comprehensive state continuation benefits.

You'll need systems for tracking qualifying events, sending required notices within specified timeframes, and coordinating with your insurance carrier to ensure seamless coverage transitions. The notice requirements are strict—missing deadlines can expose your company to liability.

Consider how this benefit integrates with your other employee offerings. If you provide other post-employment benefits like life insurance conversion options, coordination becomes more complex but also more valuable to departing employees.

Professional Support Makes the Difference

Managing continuation coverage compliance while running your core business can be overwhelming. This is where professional plan administration support becomes invaluable. At Benton Oakfield, we handle the complex tracking, notice requirements, and carrier coordination so you can focus on your business.

We work specifically with Long Island businesses like yours, understanding the unique challenges facing professional service firms, medical practices, and growing companies in Nassau and Suffolk counties. Our team ensures your continuation coverage programs meet both federal and New York state requirements while maximizing the value to your employees.

Ready to ensure your business stays compliant while offering competitive benefits? Contact our team to review your current continuation coverage setup and identify any gaps that need attention.

Compliance Note: Benefit plan rules and tax implications vary based on company size and location. This guide is for educational purposes only. Please contact your Benton Oakfield representative to discuss how this applies to your specific situation.

Photo by fauxels on Pexels