DOL Audits: What Small Business Owners Need to Know

As a business owner offering employee benefits, you might think audits are something that only happens to large corporations. The reality is that the Department of Labor (DOL) audits businesses of all sizes, and small to medium companies are often less prepared when they come knocking. Understanding how DOL audits work can help you avoid costly penalties and sleepless nights.

What is a DOL Audit?

A Department of Labor audit is an official investigation into how your company manages employee benefit plans. Think of it like a financial inspection - DOL investigators review your benefit plan documents, procedures, and records to ensure you're following federal laws, primarily the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA).

ERISA governs most employer-sponsored benefit plans, including health insurance, retirement plans, and disability benefits. If you offer these benefits to employees, you're subject to ERISA rules and potential DOL scrutiny.

What Triggers a DOL Audit?

DOL audits can happen for several reasons, and many are completely random. However, certain situations increase your chances of being selected:

• Employee complaints: When current or former employees file complaints about benefit plan issues
• Late or missing filings: Failing to submit required Form 5500 annual reports on time
• Industry targeting: The DOL sometimes focuses on specific industries or geographic areas
• Random selection: Your business might simply be chosen at random from filing databases
• Plan terminations: Closing or significantly changing benefit plans can trigger review

What Do DOL Auditors Review?

During an audit, DOL investigators examine several key areas of your benefit plan administration:

Plan documents and disclosures: They'll want to see your summary plan descriptions, employee handbooks, and all communication about benefits. These documents must be complete, accurate, and distributed properly to employees.

Fiduciary responsibilities: As an employer offering benefits, you have fiduciary duties - meaning you must act in employees' best interests when managing their benefit plans. Auditors review how you select insurance carriers, make plan changes, and handle employee funds.

Claims handling: They examine how benefit claims are processed, whether appeals are handled properly, and if employees receive required notices about claim decisions.

Financial records: For self-funded plans or those involving employer contributions, auditors review financial transactions, investment decisions, and fund management.

Document Retention: Your Best Defense

Good record-keeping is your strongest protection during a DOL audit. You're required to maintain benefit plan records for at least six years, but keeping them longer is often wise.

Essential documents include plan documents, employee communications, claim files, financial records, meeting minutes about benefit decisions, and vendor contracts. Organize these records systematically - scrambling to find documents during an audit creates a poor impression and wastes valuable time.

How to Respond to a DOL Audit

If the DOL contacts you about an audit, don't panic, but do take it seriously. Here's how to handle the situation professionally:

Respond promptly: Acknowledge their contact immediately and provide requested documents within specified timeframes. Delays can be interpreted as non-cooperation.

Be cooperative but cautious: Answer questions honestly and completely, but don't volunteer information beyond what's requested. Consider having legal counsel review your responses.

Stay organized: Provide documents in an organized, professional manner. Create indexes and explanations to help auditors understand your systems.

Designate a point person: Have one knowledgeable person handle all DOL communications to ensure consistency and prevent mixed messages.

Common Compliance Failures to Avoid

Many DOL violations stem from simple oversights that small businesses can easily prevent:

• Missing or inadequate plan documents: Ensure all benefit plans have proper written documentation
• Poor employee communication: Provide required notices about benefits, changes, and rights in clear, understandable language
• Inconsistent plan administration: Apply benefit rules consistently across all employees
• Delayed claim processing: Handle benefit claims within required timeframes and provide proper appeal processes
• Inadequate vendor oversight: Monitor third-party administrators and insurance carriers to ensure they're meeting their obligations

The Cost of Non-Compliance

DOL violations can result in significant penalties, even for small businesses. Beyond financial penalties, non-compliance can damage employee relationships, create legal liability, and consume enormous amounts of management time.

More importantly, compliance failures often indicate that employees aren't receiving the full value of their benefits - which defeats the purpose of offering these valuable recruiting and retention tools.

How Professional Benefits Administration Helps

Managing benefit plan compliance while running your business is challenging, especially when regulations change frequently. This is where professional benefits administration becomes invaluable.

At Benton Oakfield, we help Long Island businesses maintain DOL compliance through proper plan documentation, employee communication, and ongoing administration support. Our ERISA compliance services ensure your benefit plans meet federal requirements while maximizing their value to your employees.

We handle the complex paperwork, maintain required documentation, and provide ongoing support so you can focus on growing your business rather than worrying about compliance issues.

Don't wait until you receive an audit notice to address benefit plan compliance. Contact us today to review your current benefit plans and ensure they meet DOL requirements.

Compliance Note: Benefit plan rules and tax implications vary based on company size and location. This guide is for educational purposes only. Please contact your Benton Oakfield representative to discuss how this applies to your specific situation.

Photo by fauxels on Pexels