ERISA Fiduciary Responsibilities: A Guide for Employers

If your Long Island business offers retirement plans like 401(k)s or group health insurance, you might be an ERISA fiduciary without even knowing it. This designation comes with serious legal responsibilities that can expose you to personal liability if not handled properly. Understanding these duties is crucial for protecting both your employees and your business.

What Is an ERISA Fiduciary?

Under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), a fiduciary is anyone who exercises control over employee benefit plans or plan assets. Think of it like being a trustee - you're legally obligated to act in your employees' best interests, not your own.

You become a fiduciary if you:

• Select or monitor investment options in your 401(k) plan
• Choose insurance carriers or third-party administrators
• Make decisions about plan design or features
• Have authority to appoint other service providers
• Provide investment advice to employees

Many business owners assume their payroll company or insurance broker handles everything, but the buck stops with you as the plan sponsor. Even delegating responsibilities doesn't eliminate your fiduciary duties entirely.

The Prudent Person Standard

ERISA requires fiduciaries to act with the care of a "prudent person" - essentially, someone who is knowledgeable about employee benefits and investments. This means you must:

• Make informed decisions based on thorough research
• Diversify investment options to minimize risk
• Monitor plan performance regularly
• Keep detailed records of your decision-making process
• Act solely in participants' best interests

The law doesn't expect you to be a benefits expert, but it does require you to either educate yourself or work with qualified professionals who can guide your decisions.

Prohibited Transactions to Avoid

ERISA strictly forbids certain transactions between your business and employee benefit plans. These "prohibited transactions" include:

• Using plan assets for company loans or investments
• Purchasing goods or services from the plan for your business
• Having the plan invest in your company stock (with limited exceptions)
• Receiving kickbacks or excessive compensation from service providers
• Self-dealing that benefits you personally rather than plan participants

Violating these rules can result in hefty penalties and personal liability. The key principle is maintaining clear separation between plan assets and company interests.

Understanding Your Liability Exposure

Fiduciary breaches can be expensive. You could be personally liable for:

• Restoring losses to the plan caused by your actions
• Returning any profits you made from improper use of plan assets
• Civil penalties imposed by the Department of Labor
• Legal fees and court costs
• Removal from your fiduciary position

Unlike many business risks, fiduciary liability often isn't covered by standard business insurance policies. The personal nature of this liability makes it particularly serious for business owners.

Best Practices for ERISA Fiduciaries

Protecting yourself starts with establishing solid processes:

Document Everything: Keep detailed records of meetings, decisions, and the reasoning behind benefit plan choices. This documentation can be crucial if your decisions are ever questioned.

Establish a Committee: Consider forming a benefits committee with multiple decision-makers. This spreads responsibility and brings different perspectives to important choices.

Monitor Service Providers: Regularly review the performance and fees of your insurance carriers, record-keepers, and investment managers. What seemed reasonable five years ago might not be competitive today.

Stay Educated: The benefits landscape changes constantly. Attend seminars, read industry updates, or work with professionals who can keep you informed of new developments.

Get Professional Help: Partner with qualified advisors who understand ERISA requirements and can help you navigate complex decisions.

How Employees Benefit from Proper Fiduciary Management

When you fulfill your fiduciary duties properly, employees get:

• Better investment options with competitive fees
• Clear communication about their benefits
• Confidence that their retirement assets are protected
• Regular plan improvements and updates
• Professional oversight of their benefit programs

Employees rarely think about fiduciary responsibilities, but they definitely notice when plans are well-managed versus neglected.

Key Considerations for Long Island Businesses

Small and medium businesses face unique challenges with ERISA compliance. You're expected to meet the same standards as Fortune 500 companies, but with fewer resources and expertise. Consider these factors:

Time commitment required for proper oversight, cost of professional guidance versus potential liability, complexity of managing multiple service provider relationships, and ongoing education needed to stay current with regulations.

The good news is that proper fiduciary management often leads to better employee benefits at lower costs, making it a worthwhile investment in your business.

How Benton Oakfield Helps Long Island Businesses

Managing ERISA fiduciary responsibilities doesn't have to keep you up at night. At Benton Oakfield, we help Long Island business owners navigate these complex requirements while focusing on what they do best - running their businesses.

Our ERISA compliance services include fiduciary education, documentation support, service provider monitoring, and ongoing guidance to protect you from liability while maximizing employee satisfaction with their benefits.

We understand the unique challenges facing medical practices, dental offices, accounting firms, law firms, and other professional service businesses throughout Nassau and Suffolk Counties. Our goal is to make ERISA compliance straightforward and manageable.

Ready to ensure your business is properly protected? Contact our team to discuss your specific fiduciary responsibilities and how we can help you meet them effectively.

Compliance Note: Benefit plan rules and tax implications vary based on company size and location. This guide is for educational purposes only. Please contact your Benton Oakfield representative to discuss how this applies to your specific situation.

Photo by Christina Morillo on Pexels