Long Island Employers: Critical Updates to New York Disability Benefits Law in 2026

Under New York's Workers' Compensation Law Article 9, virtually all private employers in Nassau and Suffolk Counties must provide Disability Benefits coverage to employees, with maximum employee contributions capped at $0.60 per week or 0.5% of wages. This state-mandated program covers off-the-job injuries and illnesses, creating a critical safety net that Long Island business owners must understand and properly administer in 2026.

Understanding New York's Disability Benefits Law Requirements

New York's Disability Benefits Law (DBL) has been a cornerstone of employee protection for decades, but ongoing compliance remains essential for Long Island employers. According to the New York State Workers' Compensation Board, this mandatory program provides cash benefits to eligible employees who become disabled due to injuries or illnesses that occur outside of work.

The distinction between workers' compensation and disability benefits is critical. While workers' compensation covers job-related injuries and illnesses, DBL specifically addresses conditions that are not work-related—a broken leg from a skiing accident, recovery from surgery, or complications from pregnancy, for example. This complementary coverage ensures employees have income protection regardless of where or how a disability occurs.

Employers must secure DBL coverage through either a state-approved insurance carrier or by applying for self-insurance status with the Workers' Compensation Board. The coverage must remain active and in good standing at all times. Any lapse in coverage exposes your business to significant penalties and potential legal liability if an employee experiences a qualifying disability during the gap.

The maximum employee contribution structure remains straightforward: employees can be charged up to $0.60 per week, or 0.5% of their wages, whichever amount is less. This means for most employees, the weekly deduction will be minimal—typically less than the cost of a cup of coffee—but the protection it provides during a serious health event can be financially crucial.

Which Long Island Businesses Must Comply

The scope of New York's Disability Benefits Law is intentionally broad. If you operate a private business in Nassau and Suffolk Counties and employ one or more people for at least 30 days, you must provide DBL coverage. This includes businesses of all sizes, from small retail shops employing a handful of part-time workers to mid-sized manufacturing facilities with dozens of full-time employees.

The law applies across all industries operating on Long Island. Professional services firms, healthcare practices, construction companies, hospitality businesses, retail establishments, and technology startups all fall under the same mandate. Even if you have just one employee working part-time, compliance is required once that employment relationship extends beyond 30 days.

Certain employee categories may have specific eligibility requirements, but the employer's obligation to secure and maintain coverage remains constant. Employees must be employed at the time their disability begins and the condition must not be work-related to qualify for benefits under this program.

Compliance Requirements and Penalties

Long Island employers face several specific compliance obligations under New York's Disability Benefits Law. First and foremost, you must secure approved DBL coverage before your first employee completes 30 days of work. This means new business owners need to address disability benefits insurance during their initial setup phase, not after they've already begun operations.

Second, you must post the required DBL notice in a conspicuous location where employees can easily see it. This notice, provided by your insurance carrier or available from the Workers' Compensation Board, explains employee rights under the program and how to file a claim. Failure to post this notice is a compliance violation even if your coverage is otherwise in place.

Third, you must properly calculate and collect employee contributions through payroll deductions. The maximum deduction of $0.60 per week or 0.5% of wages must be applied consistently and accurately. These contributions offset a portion of the premium cost, though employers typically bear the majority of the expense.

The penalties for non-compliance are substantial. Operating without required DBL coverage can result in significant fines from the Workers' Compensation Board. More seriously, if an employee becomes disabled while you lack coverage, you may be personally liable for paying benefits directly to that employee—an obligation that could extend for weeks or months depending on the disability duration. Additionally, you could face legal action from both the state and affected employees.

For businesses managing multiple compliance requirements simultaneously, integrating DBL administration with your broader compliance services strategy helps ensure nothing falls through the cracks.

Action Steps for Nassau and Suffolk County Employers

Take these specific steps to ensure your Long Island business maintains full compliance with New York's Disability Benefits Law in 2026:

1. Verify your current coverage status – Contact your DBL insurance carrier to confirm your policy is active and in good standing. Request updated certificates of insurance and verify that all employee classifications are properly covered under your policy.
2. Audit your payroll deductions – Review your payroll system to ensure DBL contributions are being calculated and collected correctly. Confirm you're not exceeding the maximum weekly deduction of $0.60 or 0.5% of wages, whichever is less.
3. Update workplace postings – Check that the required DBL notice is posted prominently in your workplace. If you have multiple locations across Nassau and Suffolk Counties, each location needs its own posting. Replace any outdated notices with current versions.
4. Train your HR and payroll staff – Ensure everyone responsible for benefits administration understands the difference between workers' compensation, DBL, and Paid Family Leave. These three programs often create confusion, but they serve distinct purposes and have different eligibility criteria.
5. Document your compliance procedures – Create a simple checklist or procedure document that outlines how your business maintains DBL compliance. Include carrier contact information, renewal dates, posting requirements, and the process for handling employee disability claims.
6. Review your broader benefits strategy – DBL provides a baseline level of protection, but many Long Island employers enhance this coverage with supplemental disability insurance or other employee benefits that provide more comprehensive income protection during extended disabilities.

How Benton Oakfield Supports Long Island Employers

Managing New York's various mandatory benefit programs—Disability Benefits Law, Paid Family Leave, workers' compensation—requires careful attention and local expertise. At Benton Oakfield, we help Nassau and Suffolk County businesses navigate these requirements as part of our comprehensive approach to plan administration. Our team ensures your mandatory coverage remains compliant while integrating seamlessly with your voluntary benefit offerings.

For questions about your DBL compliance or to review your complete benefits program, contact Thomas Hart and the Benton Oakfield team at +1 212-365-4553.

Compliance Note: Benefit plan rules and tax implications vary based on company size and location. This summary is for informational purposes only. Please contact your Benton Oakfield representative to review how these changes impact your specific plan documents.

Photo by Darlene Alderson on Pexels