Making Your Benefits Investment Pay Off in 2026

You're spending $2,000-$4,000 per employee annually on benefits packages, but here's the problem: most of your staff can't tell you what dental coverage they have or how much life insurance you're providing. That's money with zero return on investment.

Now that the 2026 enrollment period has ended, January is the perfect time to ensure your benefits investment actually works for your business. The difference between benefits that retain employees and benefits that drain your budget often comes down to one factor: whether your team understands what you're providing.

The Hidden Cost of Invisible Benefits

Nassau and Suffolk County employers typically offer dental, vision, life insurance, and disability coverage as part of their total compensation package. But when employees don't understand these benefits, they can't appreciate them – which means you get zero credit as an employer for thousands of dollars in annual spending.

Consider the math: if you're paying $150 per month for an employee's dental coverage but they visit an out-of-network dentist because they don't understand their plan, they're paying out-of-pocket while you're still paying premiums. The employee sees an expense, not a benefit.

The same pattern repeats across all ancillary benefits. Employees who don't understand their disability coverage won't value the income protection you're providing. Staff who don't know their life insurance amounts can't factor that security into their overall compensation satisfaction.

Beyond Open Enrollment: Ongoing Education

Most Long Island businesses handle benefits enrollment once per year, then assume employees remember everything. But benefits utilization data tells a different story – employees frequently make choices that cost them money because they don't understand their options.

According to recent small business research, companies that invest in employee education see higher satisfaction scores and lower turnover rates. The key is treating benefits communication as an ongoing business function, not a once-yearly event.

Maximizing Your 2026 Benefits ROI

With enrollment behind you, focus on these areas where employee understanding directly impacts your bottom line:

• Dental and Vision Networks: Employees who use in-network providers cost you less in claims and appreciate their coverage more. Make sure they have current provider directories and understand the cost difference.
• FSA and HSA Usage: Money left in flexible spending accounts at year-end represents benefits dollars that provided zero value. Employees need ongoing reminders about eligible expenses and deadlines.
• Preventive Care: Most health plans cover annual physicals, mammograms, and colonoscopies at 100%. Employees who use preventive care have fewer expensive emergency claims later.
• Life and Disability Benefits: Employees who understand these protections are more likely to stay with employers who provide them, especially in uncertain economic times.

The Retention Factor

Long Island's competitive job market means employees have options. But benefits only retain employees if they understand and value what you're providing. An employee who doesn't know you pay for their short-term disability coverage won't factor that protection into their decision to stay or leave.

Professional services firms, medical practices, and small businesses across Nassau and Suffolk County are discovering that benefits education directly impacts retention rates. When employees understand the full value of their compensation package, they're less likely to be swayed by salary offers from competitors who may offer less comprehensive benefits.

Making Benefits Work for Your Business

The most successful Long Island employers treat benefits as a year-round communication priority. They provide regular updates about plan changes, send reminders about underutilized benefits, and help employees make informed decisions about their coverage.

Rather than viewing benefits administration as a compliance requirement, these businesses use their benefits package as a competitive advantage in recruitment and retention. But that advantage only works when employees understand what they're receiving.

Your 2026 benefits investment is already committed. The question now is whether you'll get the retention and recruitment value you're paying for, or whether those thousands of dollars per employee will remain invisible to the people you're trying to retain.

Benton Oakfield's ongoing benefits education ensures your employees understand and appreciate the coverage you provide. Our quarterly check-ins and employee communication programs turn your benefits spending into an actual retention tool, not just another line item on your P&L.

Compliance Note: Benefit plan rules and tax implications vary based on company size and location. This summary is for informational purposes only. Please contact your Benton Oakfield representative to review how these changes impact your specific plan documents.

Photo by Christina Morillo on Pexels