New York Caps Insulin at $35 - What Employers Should Know

New York's insulin cost cap took effect January 1, 2026, limiting what your employees with diabetes pay to $35 per month for their medication. If your Long Island business offers group health coverage, this mandate is already built into your plan - but it's part of a larger trend that's pushing premiums higher across the state.

The insulin cap applies to most group health plans, meaning employees with diabetes on your medical coverage won't pay more than $35 monthly for their insulin, regardless of the plan's formulary or tier structure. This represents significant savings for affected employees, as insulin can cost hundreds of dollars per month without coverage.

The High-Deductible Plan Exception

There's one important caveat business owners need to understand: the $35 cap doesn't apply to high-deductible health plans until the employee meets their annual deductible. According to New York Public Radio, this exception stems from federal regulations governing these plans, which generally require all costs except preventive care to count toward the deductible.

For employers offering high-deductible plans paired with Health Savings Accounts, this means diabetic employees will still pay full insulin costs until they hit their deductible threshold - potentially $1,500 for individual coverage or $3,000 for family coverage in 2026.

The Premium Impact You're Already Feeling

While the insulin cap helps employees, it's contributing to the premium increases Long Island employers faced during their recent renewals. Insurance carriers point to New York's 70+ state benefit mandates as a key driver of rising costs. Each mandate - from insulin caps to mental health coverage requirements - adds to the overall cost pool that gets distributed across all policyholders.

Nassau and Suffolk County employers with 10-50 employees are feeling this squeeze particularly hard. Unlike large corporations that can spread mandate costs across thousands of employees, smaller groups see these requirements translate directly into higher per-employee premiums. The insulin cap joins mandates for autism coverage, fertility treatments, and preventive care that all add layers of required benefits to your group health coverage.

Compliance Is Automatic, But Communication Isn't

The good news for employers is that compliance with the insulin cap is automatic - your insurance carrier has already built it into your 2026 plan design. You don't need to file additional paperwork or notify anyone that you're complying with the mandate.

However, employees with diabetes might not realize this benefit exists unless you tell them. During the enrollment rush, this detail could have been buried in plan documents or summary of benefits. Employees who stopped filling insulin prescriptions due to cost might not know they can now get them for $35 monthly.

What This Means for Your Bottom Line

The insulin cap represents a microcosm of New York's approach to health insurance regulation: employee-friendly mandates that improve coverage but increase costs for employers. While you can't opt out of state mandates, you can work with an experienced broker to find plans that manage these costs effectively.

Some carriers are better at pricing mandated benefits than others. Some offer disease management programs that help diabetic employees manage their condition more effectively, potentially reducing your group's overall claims. These nuances matter when you're comparing renewal options or mid-year alternatives.

For professional practices, accounting firms, and other Long Island businesses competing for talent, comprehensive coverage that includes meaningful benefits like the insulin cap can be a recruitment advantage. But only if you're not overpaying for that coverage relative to your local market.

Planning for Future Mandate Costs

The insulin cap won't be the last mandate affecting your group health costs. New York regularly adds required benefits, and each one incrementally increases what you pay per employee. Smart employers build this reality into their benefits budget planning and work with brokers who understand how to navigate the mandate landscape.

Rather than simply accepting whatever renewal increase your carrier proposes, experienced brokers can help you understand which mandates are driving your specific cost increases and whether alternative plan designs or carriers handle those requirements more cost-effectively.

Compliance Note: Benefit plan rules and tax implications vary based on company size and location. This summary is for informational purposes only. Please contact your Benton Oakfield representative to review how these changes impact your specific plan documents.

Photo by Negative Space on Pexels