Nondiscrimination Testing: What Long Island Employers Need to Know

As a business owner on Long Island, you work hard to provide competitive benefits that attract and retain good employees. But did you know that the IRS requires many employee benefit plans to pass annual "fairness tests" to ensure they don't disproportionately favor higher-paid employees? This process is called nondiscrimination testing, and failing these tests can result in significant penalties and tax consequences.

Let's break down what nondiscrimination testing means for your business and how to navigate these requirements successfully.

What Is Nondiscrimination Testing?

Think of nondiscrimination testing as the IRS's way of ensuring that employee benefit plans are truly "fair" across all income levels within your company. The government provides tax advantages for certain employee benefits, but in exchange, they want to make sure these benefits aren't just perks for executives and highly compensated employees.

The testing compares how much highly compensated employees (HCEs) participate in and benefit from your plans versus non-highly compensated employees (NHCEs). If the highly paid employees are getting disproportionately more value from the benefits, the plan fails the test.

Types of Nondiscrimination Testing

There are several key types of testing that may apply to your business:

• Section 125 Cafeteria Plan Testing: If you offer a cafeteria plan that allows employees to pay for benefits with pre-tax dollars (like health insurance premiums or FSA contributions), this plan must be tested annually
• Health Plan Testing: Group health insurance plans must demonstrate they don't discriminate in favor of highly compensated employees in terms of eligibility or benefits
• Dependent Care FSA Testing: If you offer dependent care flexible spending accounts, these require separate nondiscrimination testing
• Group Term Life Insurance Testing: Employer-provided life insurance benefits above certain thresholds must pass nondiscrimination tests

How the Testing Process Works

The testing process typically follows these steps:

Data Collection: Your benefits administrator gathers detailed information about employee compensation, benefit elections, and participation rates. This includes identifying which employees qualify as highly compensated based on current IRS thresholds.

Mathematical Analysis: Complex calculations compare participation rates and benefit levels between highly compensated and non-highly compensated employee groups. Different tests have different mathematical formulas and passing thresholds.

Results Review: If your plans pass all applicable tests, you're in compliance for that year. If any test fails, corrective action is required.

Corrections if Needed: Failed tests typically require refunding excess contributions to highly compensated employees or providing additional benefits to non-highly compensated employees.

Why Employers Need to Take This Seriously

Nondiscrimination testing isn't optional—it's a federal requirement that comes with real consequences. Here's why it matters for your business:

Avoid Penalties: Failed tests can result in loss of tax-favored status for your benefit plans, meaning employees lose tax savings and your company may face penalties.

Protect Tax Savings: The pre-tax treatment of many benefits depends on passing these tests. Failure can turn tax-free benefits into taxable income for employees.

Maintain Employee Trust: Having to claw back benefits or impose tax consequences on employees after the fact can damage morale and trust.

Stay Competitive: Compliant benefit plans help you offer competitive packages that attract and retain talent in Long Island's competitive job market.

Testing Timeline and Deadlines

Most nondiscrimination testing follows an annual cycle:

• Testing is typically performed after the plan year ends
• Results must be available by the tax filing deadline (including extensions)
• Any required corrections must usually be completed within a specific timeframe, often within the following plan year
• Some plans may require quarterly or periodic testing throughout the year

Key Considerations for Long Island Businesses

Several factors can affect your testing results and compliance strategy:

Company Demographics: Businesses with a large gap between highly paid and lower-paid employees often face greater testing challenges. Professional service firms like law practices or medical offices may need extra attention to testing compliance.

Benefit Design: How you structure your benefit offerings can impact testing results. Sometimes small changes to plan design can help ensure compliance.

Employee Communication: Encouraging broader participation among all employee groups, not just executives, can help plans pass testing requirements.

Record Keeping: Accurate payroll and benefits data is essential for proper testing. Small errors in data can lead to incorrect test results.

How Benton Oakfield Simplifies Nondiscrimination Testing

Managing nondiscrimination testing requirements can be complex and time-consuming for busy Long Island business owners. That's where professional plan administration services become invaluable.

At Benton Oakfield, we handle the entire testing process for our clients—from data collection and analysis to reporting results and implementing any necessary corrections. We understand the unique challenges faced by medical practices, dental offices, accounting firms, and other professional service businesses throughout Nassau and Suffolk Counties.

Our team stays current on changing regulations and testing requirements, so you don't have to worry about missing deadlines or failing compliance requirements. We also work with you throughout the year to design benefit programs that are more likely to pass testing, rather than simply reacting to problems after they occur.

Don't let nondiscrimination testing requirements put your business at risk or consume valuable time you could spend growing your practice. Contact our team today to learn how we can handle these complex requirements while you focus on what you do best.

Compliance Note: Benefit plan rules and tax implications vary based on company size and location. This guide is for educational purposes only. Please contact your Benton Oakfield representative to discuss how this applies to your specific situation.

Photo by fauxels on Pexels