Pharmacy Benefit Managers (PBMs) Explained for Employers

When you offer health insurance to your employees, prescription drug coverage is typically included. But have you ever wondered who actually manages those prescription benefits behind the scenes? Enter Pharmacy Benefit Managers (PBMs) – the invisible middlemen who play a massive role in your employees' prescription drug costs and coverage.

Understanding how PBMs work is crucial for any business owner evaluating health plans. These companies directly impact what your employees pay at the pharmacy counter and how much your business spends on prescription drug benefits.

What Is a Pharmacy Benefit Manager?

Think of a PBM as the traffic controller for prescription drugs. Just like an air traffic controller manages which planes can land at which gates, a PBM manages which drugs are covered by your health plan, where employees can fill prescriptions, and how much everyone pays.

PBMs act as intermediaries between your health insurance plan, pharmaceutical companies, pharmacies, and your employees. The largest PBMs in the country process billions of prescriptions annually and have enormous influence over drug pricing and access.

How PBMs Work: The Step-by-Step Process

Here's what happens when your employee goes to fill a prescription:

• Coverage Check: The pharmacy submits the prescription to the PBM's system to verify coverage under your plan
• Formulary Review: The PBM checks if the drug is on the plan's formulary (approved drug list) and at what tier
• Cost Calculation: The PBM determines the employee's copay or coinsurance based on your plan design
• Claims Processing: If approved, the PBM processes the claim and pays the pharmacy
• Member Communication: If there's an issue, the PBM may suggest alternatives or require prior authorization

This entire process typically happens in seconds at the pharmacy counter, but the PBM's influence extends far beyond claims processing.

How PBMs Influence Drug Costs

PBMs use their massive purchasing power to negotiate with drug manufacturers. Here's where it gets interesting for your business:

Formulary Management: PBMs create lists of preferred drugs (formularies) for each plan tier. Drugs on preferred tiers cost employees less out-of-pocket. PBMs negotiate with manufacturers to secure lower prices in exchange for favorable formulary placement.

Rebates and Discounts: Pharmaceutical companies pay rebates to PBMs for including their drugs on formularies or giving them preferred status. These rebates can be passed through to your plan, potentially lowering your overall costs.

Pharmacy Networks: PBMs contract with pharmacy chains and independent pharmacies, negotiating reimbursement rates. Employees typically pay less at in-network pharmacies.

Why Understanding PBMs Matters for Your Business

As a business owner, PBM performance directly impacts your bottom line and employee satisfaction:

Cost Control: PBMs with better negotiating power and rebate programs can significantly reduce your prescription drug spending. For a business with 25 employees, this could mean thousands in annual savings.

Employee Experience: The PBM determines which pharmacies your employees can use, how quickly prior authorizations get processed, and whether they can access specialty medications easily.

Predictable Budgeting: Some PBMs offer more transparent pricing models, making it easier to forecast your benefits costs from year to year.

What Your Employees Experience

From your employees' perspective, the PBM shapes their entire prescription drug experience:

• Which medications are covered and at what cost
• Whether they need prior authorization for certain drugs
• Which pharmacies they can use
• Access to mail-order pharmacy options
• Availability of generic drug programs
• Customer service when they have questions or problems

A good PBM makes the process seamless. A poor one creates frustration, delays, and unexpected costs that can hurt employee morale.

Key Considerations When Evaluating PBMs

When reviewing health plans, here are important PBM-related questions to ask:

• Transparency: Does the PBM provide clear reporting on rebates and how they're applied to your plan?
• Network Size: How many pharmacies are in-network, and are they convenient for your employees?
• Formulary Management: How often does the formulary change, and how are members notified?
• Prior Authorization: What's the process for getting expensive medications approved?
• Customer Service: What support is available when employees have prescription issues?
• Cost Structure: Are there hidden fees or charges beyond the obvious costs?

How Benton Oakfield Helps Navigate PBM Complexity

PBM evaluation requires expertise that most business owners don't have time to develop. At Benton Oakfield, we analyze PBM performance as part of our comprehensive benefits consulting services. We review formularies, compare network access, and evaluate cost structures to ensure your employees get the prescription coverage they need at a price your business can afford.

We also help your employees understand how to maximize their prescription benefits, reducing confusion and improving satisfaction with the coverage you provide. Our Long Island focus means we understand which pharmacy networks work best for your employees' daily routines.

Rather than leaving PBM evaluation to chance, let us help you make informed decisions that control costs while keeping your team healthy and productive. Contact us to discuss how PBM analysis fits into your overall benefits strategy.

Compliance Note: Benefit plan rules and tax implications vary based on company size and location. This guide is for educational purposes only. Please contact your Benton Oakfield representative to discuss how this applies to your specific situation.

Photo by RDNE Stock project on Pexels